Skip to main content
Lead Generation

Should I buy exclusive leads or shared leads?

Last reviewed 22 April 2026 · Reviewed by Jake McQuillan

Quick answer

Should I buy exclusive leads or shared leads?

Exclusive leads — generated for you alone — almost always outperform shared lead-aggregator leads on conversion, compliance and lifetime value. Shared leads are cheaper per unit but typically convert 3 to 10x worse and create compliance risk.

Want us to do this for your firm?
Get a compliant lead-gen plan tailored to your niche and compliance setup.
Book a discovery call

The difference

  • Exclusive: generated by or for your firm only. Single firm contacts the prospect.
  • Shared: sold to 4 to 8 firms by a lead aggregator. Prospect is contacted repeatedly within minutes.

Why exclusive wins

  1. Conversion to client: 15 to 35% exclusive vs 2 to 8% shared.
  2. Lifetime value: exclusive leads stay with you; shared churn quickly.
  3. Compliance: you own the consent and source, not a third party.
  4. Brand equity: every ad click reinforces your brand.

When shared can work

  • You have 24/7 speed-to-lead capability.
  • You can operate at very high volume and low-margin.
  • You are topping up a mature pipeline, not building it.
Was this useful?
JM
Reviewed by
Jake McQuillan
Founder at Platinum Prospects
Last reviewed 22 April 2026

Ask your own question

Describe your firm’s situation and we’ll reply with a tailored answer and benchmarks.

We’ll email you once with an answer. No marketing sequences.

Related questions

Should I gate financial content behind a lead form?
Gate high value personalised tools (calculators, cashflow previews). Keep educational articles, definitions and statistics open gating hurts SEO and AI citatio…
What is the best lead magnet for financial advisers in 2025?
A scenario specific tool (cashflow preview, pension value calculator, IHT mini calculator) outperforms static PDFs 2 3x in lead quality and downstream conversi…
Why does paid lead generation fail for some financial advisers?
The five most common causes: (1) unclear niche, (2) weak offer, (3) no speed to lead, (4) no offline conversion tracking, (5) compliance delays. Fixing 2 of th…
Should a financial adviser niche down, and how?
Yes. Single niche advisers outperform generalists on CPL (30 to 60% lower), conversion (2 to 3x higher), and LTV. Niche down by: (1) advice area, (2) client de…
What is a good cost per lead for UK financial advisers?
For UK financial advisers, a healthy cost per lead sits between £48 and £420 depending on niche. Pensions and equity release cluster around £120 to £280, mortg…